Recent cases
IP
Interflora v Marks & Spencer
IP Translator
Deakin v Cardrax
National Starch/Brunob II
Michael Cohen
X v Y (parties identities confidential)
Arevdour Ltd v Küçükçalik
In a claim for breach of an agency agreement and for breach of copyright in fabric designs, the Defendant successfully applied to discharge an interim copyright injunction and a freezing order.
Research in Motion UK Ltd v Motorola Inc
Infringement and validity action concerning complex telecommunications patents.
Red Spider Technology v Omega Completions Technolo
Claim for infringement of patent and unregistered design for oil well valve rejected. [2010] EWHC 59 (Ch)
Diageo North America v Intercontinental Brands (“Vodkat")
Extended passing off case in the alcoholic drinks industry. [2010] EWHC 17 (Ch)
Sun Microsystems v M Tech and others
An important case on the validity of the exercise of trademark rights against imports from outside the EEA [2010] ETMR 13
Boegli-Gravures v Darsail
Successful claim for patent infringement in the tobacco industry. [2009] EWHC 2690 (Pat)
Daimler v Sany
Action for infringement of Mercedes’ three-pointed star trade mark, alleging the taking of unfair advantage. [2009] EWHC 2581 (Ch)
Grisbrook v MGN
Judge refused to commit defendant for breach of consent order. [2009] EWHC 2520
Healthcare Locums Plc v Urban Recruitment
Acting for the successful claimants seeking interim relief and then summary judgment in a claim for breach of confidence, and infringement of copyright. [April and October 2009]
Bambino Mio v Cazitex
Appeal in relation to a judge’s conclusions on the likelihood of confusion. [2010] ETMR 6
Actavis v Janssen Pharmaceutica
Patent revocation action in the pharmaceuticals industry. [2008] FSR 35
L’Oreal v Bellure
Leading case concerning the meaning of “taking unfair advantage” of a trade mark’s reputation. [2010] EWCA Civ 353
FNM Corporation v Dramcock International
Claim for infringement of a patent and breach of contract dismissed. [2009] EWHC 1294 (Pat)
Edwards Lifesciences v Cook Biotech
Patent revocation action in the pharmaceuticals industry. [2009] FSR 27
Folding Attic Stairs Ltd v Loft Stairs Ltd
Patent validity and infringement action concerning a type of loft ladder [2009] FSR 24
MMI Research v Cellxion
Main decision in these long-running patent infringement and validity case concerning mobile phone security. Cellxion [2009] EWHC 418 (Pat)
Re AT&T Knowledge Ventures LP / CVON’s patent
High Court decision on patentability of computer software [2009] FSR 19
Dyson v Samsung
Patent validity case concerning cyclone technology with issues of post grant amendment [2009] FSR 15
Actavis v Novartis
Patent revocation action in the pharmaceuticals industry. [2009] EWHC 41 (Ch)
PPL v Attorney-General
Corus v Qual-Chem
Appeal concerning the permissibility of amendments to a patent. [2008] EWCA Civ 1177
TMLC & Lonsdale v Leofelis
TMLC & Lonsdale v Leofelis, [2009] EWHC 3285 (Ch) disputing the jurisdiction in a claim for breach of a trade mark licence; subsequently, successfully resisting summary judgment [2010] EWHC 969 and [2010] EWHC 1938. Also acting for Leofelis in its inquiry for damages against Lonsdale for damages for breach of its trade mark licence.
Fearns v Anglo-Dutch Paint and Chemicals
The Court of Appeal allowed in part an appeal relating to a franchise agreement. [2008] EWCA Civ 99
Early Learning Centre v Russimco
Interim injunction refused in children’s toy design right case. [2008] EWHC 264 (Ch)
D Jacobson v Globe
Trade mark infringement case relating to marks on footwear. [2008] FSR 21
Rxworks v Hunter
Summary judgment in favour of claim for unjustified threats of trade mark infringement. [2008] RPC 13
Vector v Glatt
Important Court of Appeal decision concerning post-grant amendment of patent [2008] RPC 10
Procter & Gamble v Reckitt Benckiser
Leading Court of Appeal authority on the validity and infringement of Community designs. [2008] FSR 8
Bignell v Just Employment Law
Passing off and trade mark infringement action between two solicitors. [2008] FSR 6
Pozzoli v BDMO
Leading Court of Appeal authority on the assessment of obviousness in patent cases. [2007] FSR 37
Riemann v Linco Care
Interim injunction granted in a claim relating to passing off and infringement of Community trade marks. [2007] ECC 23
LIFFE v Pinkava
Seminal Court of Appeal case on ownership of inventions between employer and employee [2007] RPC 30
Nova Productions v Mazooma Games
The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal against a finding of non-infringement of copyright in the field of computer game design. [2007] RPC 25
Cembrit Blunn v Apotex Roofing Services
Successful claim for breach of confidence in the building materials sector. [2007] EWHC 111 (Ch)
Cembrit Blunn v Apotex Roofing Services
Successful claim for breach of confidence in the building materials sector. [2007] EWHC 111 (Ch)
IT
Research in Motion UK Ltd v Motorola Inc
Infringement and validity action concerning complex telecommunications patents.
Meridian International Services Ltd v Richardson
Court of Appeal decision in a computer software dispute [2008] EWCA Civ 609
Media & Entertainment
Chancery & Commercial
Abbas v Official Receiver
11 November 2009 – validity of the appointment of a trustee in bankruptcy.
A1 Lofts Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners
Decision concerning VAT liability in supply contracts [2009] EWHC 2694 (Ch)
Official Receiver v Mitterfellner
Decision concerning “centre of main interest” in personal insolvency [2009] BPIR 1075
Re Property Investors Courses Ltd
Appeal in public interest winding up proceedings [2008] EWCA Civ 872
Alkin v (1) Raymond and (2) Whelan
Child Maintenance and Enforcement Commission v (1) Beesley and (2) Whyman
Contact
For all queries related to cases, please contact Catherine Hanley,
Telephone +44 (0)20 7404 0404
Facsimile +44 (0)20 7404 0505
email: chanley@hogarthchambers.com
Postal Address:5 New Square
Lincoln's Inn
London
WC2A 3RJ
DX LDE 16